Skip to content
i2E
  • Programs
    • E3
    • ACT Tulsa
    • Love’s Entrepreneur’s Cup
    • OKBio
  • Client Portfolio
  • Services
    • Access to Funding
    • Venture Advisory Services
  • About
    • Our Values
    • Meet Our Team
    • Board of Directors
    • Corporate Partners
  • Contact
  • Media
Menu
  • Programs
    • E3
    • ACT Tulsa
    • Love’s Entrepreneur’s Cup
    • OKBio
  • Client Portfolio
  • Services
    • Access to Funding
    • Venture Advisory Services
  • About
    • Our Values
    • Meet Our Team
    • Board of Directors
    • Corporate Partners
  • Contact
  • Media
Search

Balance sought between technical and theoretical knowledge

Get in Touch

By Scott Meacham
Copyright © 2017, The Oklahoma Publishing Co.

Life teaches us many things if we take the time to listen. I have been privileged to serve on the Advisory Board for OU’s newly created Stephenson School of Biomedical Engineering, allowing me to be on the ground floor of building a new academic program.

The board consists of a good cross section of academics, engineering graduates and industry participants. Recently, we considered whether the program should be a thesis-based masters, or if testing to prove subject matter mastery was more beneficial. The responses and deeper issues highlighted by those responses is what I found instructive.

Representatives from industry supported the value of the in-depth research required of doctoral level graduates; however, for master’s level graduates, they favored subject matter mastery over a thesis requirement.

An academic representative on the committee questioned the value of a master’s degree without a thesis, lest the program be purely technical.

This one exchange captured the tension that exists between academia, with its focus on research, and employers, who rely upon our higher education system to teach students functional and problem-solving skills that industry requires.

At i2E, we deal with this tension every day, positioned between educational institutions and the business community as we work to commercialize innovations from Oklahoma’s universities.

In our board discussion, Michael Detamore, the founding director of this new program who has sought the advice of the board every step of the way, suggested an emerging “third rail.” What about including student projects based on solving actual clinical or industry needs in the new curriculum?

It’s an intriguing idea.

All colleges and universities fall somewhere along a continuum of a teaching mission/educating students on one end and advancing knowledge/research on the other. State supported institutions understandably tend to be tilted more toward the teaching mission while private institutions (think MIT) oftentimes tilt more, but not completely, toward the research end of the continuum.

As any participant in i2E’s Venture Assessment Program will tell you, we focus more on identifying customers and their needs than on any other aspect of building a company. So, coming back to the biomedical engineering program we are developing at OU, who is the primary “customer” and what does that customer need?

For state universities, the primary customer seems to be the student. What does the student need? My college junior might say he “needs” the social experience of college. As his parent, my answer is that he “needs” a degree that is valuable in the workplace and an education that prepares him to perform at a high level in his post-college career.

Michael Detamore’s “third rail” idea strikes an intriguing balance where students are required to identify and satisfy industry needs as part of their degree requirement.

Scott Meacham is president and CEO of i2E Inc., a nonprofit corporation that mentors many of the state’s technology-based startup companies. i2E receives state support from the Oklahoma Center for the Advancement of Science and Technology and is an integral part of Oklahoma’s Innovation Model. Contact Meacham at i2E.com.

Read the article at newsok.com

 

 

 

Author

  • Sarah Graves Sarah Graves

More News

Loading...
woman in lab conducting a study
Blog, i2E
12.13.22

Bayesic Technologies Improves Effectiveness and Efficiency of Data Analysis in Healthcare

Read more
Bison grazing fields
Blog
11.30.22

Bison Underground Merges Nature, Science, and Technology to Tackle Climate Change

Read more
African American family sitting on couch reading and chatting
Blog, E3, i2E
11.22.22

Fokes Connects Families, Caregivers and Care Agencies for Smoother Communications and Care 

Read more
i2e blog post graphic
Blog, News
11.03.22

Introducing: Stories of Oklahoma Innovation

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.28.22

Oklahoma Grown! i2E Invests in BIO startups

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

Oklahoma Medical Research Foundation BIO

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

Moleculera Labs BIO

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center BIO

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

Oklahoma State University BIO

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

ECHO Investment Capital BIO

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

AscendBioVentures BIO

Read more
Default Featured Image
OKBio
06.13.22

Dean McGee Eye Institute BIO

Read more
i2E

Oklahoma City Office

840 Research Parkway, Suite 250
OKC, OK 73104
+1 (405) 235.2305

Tulsa Office

100 S. Cincinnati Ave – Suite 514
Tulsa, OK 74103
+1 (918) 582.5592

  • Client Portfolio
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Resources

© 2022 i2E Privacy Policy

Follow us:

Facebook Twitter Linkedin

Programs

  • E3
  • ACT Tulsa
  • Love's Entrepreneur's Cup
  • OKBio
  • Client Portfolio

Services

  • Access to Funding
  • Venture Advisory Services
  • Contact
  • About
  • Our Values
  • Our Team
  • Board of Directors
  • Corporate Partners
  • Media
i2E